canada goose outlet store uk “There cannot be two sides to

Settle On A Clear Demand

Eight hundred thousand people participated in the March for Our Lives rally in Washington on March 24, say organizers with the NeverAgain movement sparked by the Parkland canada goose outlet , Florida, school massacre. The canada goose outlet black friday turnout was impressive but will it lead to new gun legislation?

canada goose premium outlet History suggests no. But canada goose outlet in usa victory is achievable if rallies are sharpened in focus. canada goose premium outlet

canada goose jacket uk The Million Moms March, also dedicated to curbing gun violence, in 2000 drew a similar sized crowd. Yet the next two decades saw one mass shooting after another, the NRA gaining rather than losing political influence, and a major reversal for the gun control movement marked by canada goose outlet online the failure to renew the ban on assault weapons. canada goose jacket uk

canada goose outlet new york city Whether it the Million Man March to promote unity and family values among African American men or the 1981 Solidarity Day march to defend unions from Reagan era attacks against organizations like the air traffic controllers union, there is a century old tradition of large groups of Americans gathering in Washington, carrying signs, chanting slogans and being ignored by Congress and the president after they go home. canada goose outlet new york city

canada goose outlet toronto location To those shattered dreams you can add 2011 Occupy Wall Street, official canada goose outlet another leaderless protest that came together and fizzled. canada goose outlet toronto location

canada goose outlet online uk At almost all canada goose outlet parka these events, speakers proclaimed themselves present at the continuation or initiation of a movement. But sustained movements must be organized. canada goose outlet online uk

These were, like the Free Speech Movement at UC Berkeley in 1964, political spasms. Perhaps not theater as farce but theater at most. At best, some presaged something later, bigger and effective.

canada goose outlet online reviews Weighing in favor of the NeverAgain movement chances of effecting real change is the role of social media, which can bring large groups of people together quickly. But they also need a simple, coherent, bumper sticker ready demand message. canada goose outlet online reviews

canada goose clothing uk Writing in USA Today, Rick Hampson argues that even the go to granddaddy of all contemporary marches, where Martin Luther King, Jr. delivered his “I Have a Dream” speech, was less effective than advertised: “Even the 1963 civil rights march required so much effort, created so many internal divisions and produced so few immediate results (the 1964 Civil Rights Act was passed only after and because of President Kennedy assassination) that its leaders canada goose outlet toronto factory vowed never to attempt another.” canada goose clothing uk

Hampson has a point. The 10 printed demands for the March on Washington canada goose outlet uk sale remind us of American society failure to address the needs of the poor and oppressed since 1963.

canada goose outlet florida Still, they had a clear, coherent set of demands, beginning with: “Comprehensive and effective Civil Rights legislation from the present Congress without compromise or filibuster to guarantee all Americans: access to all public accommodations, decent housing, adequate and integrated education, the right to vote.” canada goose outlet florida

And the Civil Rights Act did get passed.

The March 24 March for Our Lives opposed gun violence. The problem is it failed to articulate a precise demand or set of demands.

canada goose outlet trillium parka black “School safety is not a political issue,” read the Mission Statement. canada goose outlet store uk “There cannot be two sides to doing everything in our power to ensure the lives and futures canada goose outlet canada of children who are at risk of dying when they should be learning, playing, and growing. The mission and focus of March For Our Lives is to demand that a comprehensive and canada goose jacket outlet effective bill canada goose outlet store be immediately brought before Congress to address these gun issues.” canada goose outlet trillium parka black

Sorry, but those are weasel words.

Asking Congress to simply “address” an issue is an invitation for more endless debate leading nowhere, or to a compromise so watered down that it undermines the cause. (The ACA is an example of the latter.)

A movement must settle on an area of clear focus. Unlike Occupy, which was split between reformists and revolutionaries and talked about everything from restoring the Glass Steagall Act to eliminating homelessness, NeverAgain has that part down pat.

canada goose outlet eu An effective movement goose outlet canada also has to settle on the solution to a canada goose outlet uk problem. Proposing a path forward does not guarantee of success: demonstrators had a clear, straightforward demand in 2002 03: do not invade Iraq. canada goose outlet eu

canada goose uk The Bush Administration ignored them. On the other hand, it now painfully clear which side was right. That will add to the credibility of antiwar marchers the next time a president tries to canada goose outlet jackets start a war of choice. canada goose uk

canada goose outlet toronto address Settling on a clear solution, as opposed to asking the political class to “address” the issue, entails risk. For NeverAgain, advocating for a comprehensive gun ban will push away allies who prefer a compromise approach. canada goose outlet toronto address

On the other hand, a more moderate approach will generate less excitement among those in favor of a radical solution (and moderation generally elicits less enthusiasm).

But to take a page from gun toting military folks, it better to go into battle with half an army than a whole one riddled with confusion and no idea why they fighting. His next book, the graphic biography Trump, comes out July 19 and is now available for pre order. The opinions expressed are his own.

Ted Rall: America Insults Intelligent and Educated People, May 8, 2018Ted Rall: Ban Drones, Both Military and Recreational, May 1, 2018Ted Rall: Distractor In Chief Trump Is Gaslighting Us Into Forgetting America Real Issues, April 24, 2018Ted Rall: The Media Never Give Peace A Chance, April 17, 2018Ted Rall: Hiring John Bolton is Donald Trump Most Dangerous Decision, March 27, 2018Ted Rall: Democrats Should Run On Impeachment, March 20, 2018Ted Rall: Divide and Conquer, March 13, 2018Ted Rall: Never Mind Millennial Apathy, Here Generation Z, February 27, 2018

canada goose outlet new york Noozhawk Asks: What Your Question? canada goose outlet new york

canada goose outlet uk sale Welcome to Noozhawk Asks, a new feature in which you ask the questions, you help decide what Noozhawk investigates, and you work with us to find the answers. canada goose outlet uk sale

Here’s how it works: You share your questions with us in the nearby box. In some cases, we may work with you to find the answers. In others, we may ask you to vote on your top choices to help us narrow the scope. And we’ll be regularly asking you for your feedback on a specific issue or topic.

canada goose outlet price We also expect to work together with the reader who asked the winning questions to find the answer together. Noozhawk’s objective is to come at questions from a place of curiosity and openness, and canada goose outlet sale we believe a transparent collaboration is the key to achieve it canada goose outlet price.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...